Business Communication Psychology

Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well (Summary)

by Douglas Stone & Sheila Heen

Your boss tells you, 'You need to be more proactive.' Your first instinct is to get defensive, dismiss the comment as vague, and blame your boss for poor delivery. But what if the most powerful person in that conversation isn't the one giving the feedback, but the one receiving it? This book argues that seeking out and skillfully handling criticism—even when it's off-base or poorly delivered—is the single most important driver of personal and professional growth.

The Receiver Is in the Driver's Seat

We spend countless hours teaching leaders how to give feedback, but we have it backward. The receiver is the one in control, because they decide what to let in, what to make sense of, and whether to change. The real leverage is in getting better at receiving.

Imagine an aggressive, rude customer yells that your company's checkout process is 'a complete disaster.' Instead of focusing on their terrible delivery, a skilled receiver actively mines for the useful data hidden inside the bad packaging by asking, 'Can you walk me through what was so frustrating?' They take control of the learning opportunity, regardless of the giver's skill.

Separate the 'What' from the 'Who'

Our reaction to feedback is often dictated by our relationship with the person giving it. To truly learn, we must be able to disentangle the message itself (the 'what') from our feelings about the messenger and our history together (the 'who').

Your spouse tells you, 'You always leave your dishes in the sink.' Your immediate reaction might be, 'You're not perfect either! You left your towel on the floor!' This is a relationship trigger. To find the useful feedback, you have to consciously switch tracks from the relationship conflict to the actual topic and ask, 'Is it true that I often leave dishes out? What's the impact of that?'

Disarm Your Identity Triggers

Feedback can feel like a judgment on our character, triggering a defensive, 'all-or-nothing' emotional response that blocks learning. We need to learn to see feedback as information about our behavior, not an indictment of our core identity.

After a presentation, your manager says, 'You seemed nervous and rushed.' An identity trigger can cause you to think, 'I'm a failure. I'm a terrible public speaker.' A more skillful response is to contain the feedback: 'Okay, the behavior was 'rushing.' That's a specific action I can work on. It doesn't mean I'm an incompetent person.' This reframing makes the feedback manageable instead of catastrophic.

Feedback Isn't One Thing; It's Three

We often get our wires crossed because we don't realize there are three distinct types of feedback: appreciation (motivation), coaching (improvement), and evaluation (ranking). Understanding what kind of feedback you are hearing (or need to ask for) is crucial.

You ask your boss, 'How am I doing?' You are looking for evaluation (a rating), but she gives you coaching ('Maybe try outlining your reports first'). This mismatch is frustrating. To get what you need, you have to ask precisely: 'Can you give me some coaching on my report writing?' or 'When you evaluate my performance against my peers, where do I stand?'

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.