Business Marketing Entrepreneurship

The Automatic Customer: Creating a Subscription Business in Any Industry (Summary)

by John Warrillow

What do Netflix, Amazon Prime, and your local mosquito exterminator have in common? They've all cracked the code to business immortality: the subscription model. While you might think subscriptions are just for software, one pest control company increased its valuation by 800% by turning one-off bug sprays into a predictable, automatic revenue stream.

Investors Pay 8x More for Recurring Revenue

A dollar of predictable, recurring subscription revenue is valued far more highly by investors and acquirers than a dollar of transactional, one-off revenue because it provides stability and a clear forecast for future earnings.

Warrillow cites the story of Mosquito Squad, a pest control franchise. By switching from selling one-off backyard sprays to annual protection plans, they created a predictable revenue stream. This simple change in their business model increased the company's valuation from a typical one-times revenue multiple to an eight-times multiple when it was acquired.

There Are Nine Ways to Sell a Subscription

The book categorizes all subscription businesses into nine distinct models, providing a menu of options that can be adapted to almost any industry, from physical products to niche services.

The 'Consumable Model' is used by companies like Dollar Shave Club, which automatically ships you razor blades you regularly use up. In contrast, the 'Surprise Box Model,' used by Birchbox, delivers a curated selection of new items each month, selling the thrill of discovery rather than just the convenience of replenishment.

Negative Churn is the Holy Grail of Growth

The ultimate goal for a subscription business is not just to keep customers, but to have your existing customers spend more over time. This is 'negative churn'—when revenue from upgrades and add-ons from your current customer base is greater than the revenue you lose from cancellations.

A software-as-a-service (SaaS) company offers a basic plan for $20/month. A customer might upgrade to a premium $50/month plan for more features or add more user 'seats' as their own company grows. Even if a few other customers cancel that month, this one customer's expansion can lead to a net revenue gain from the existing cohort.

The Subscription Scorecard Isn't About User Count

Warrillow argues against focusing on vanity metrics like total subscribers. Instead, the health of a subscription business boils down to the critical ratio of Lifetime Value (LTV) to Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC). A sustainable business needs an LTV at least three times its CAC.

If it costs your company $100 in marketing and sales to acquire a new customer (CAC), that customer needs to generate at least $300 in profit over their entire time as a subscriber (LTV) for your business model to be scalable. Companies like Salesforce obsessively track this ratio to decide how much to spend on growth.

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.