Business Strategy Leadership

The Crux: How Leaders Become Strategists (Summary)

by Richard Rumelt

Your company's 'strategy' is probably a lie. The grand mission statements, the ambitious revenue targets, the 'Big Hairy Audacious Goals'? According to legendary strategist Richard Rumelt, this is not strategy—it's just wishful thinking. Real strategy begins by ignoring your goals and instead finding the single biggest, solvable bottleneck that, if overcome, would unlock a cascade of progress. That bottleneck is the crux.

Strategy is Problem-Solving, Not Goal-Setting

Most leaders mistakenly believe strategy is about setting inspiring goals. Rumelt argues that true strategy is the discipline of identifying the most critical challenge blocking progress and then designing a coherent approach to overcome it.

A company with a goal to 'double revenue in three years' is just stating a desire. A strategic leader would first diagnose why revenue isn't already doubling. The crux might be that the company’s best salespeople are leaving for competitors offering better commissions. The strategy, then, isn't 'sell more,' but to redesign the compensation structure to retain top talent, which will in turn drive sales.

Find the Crux, Not Just Any Problem

A crux isn't just a big problem; it's a special type of challenge that is both central to the overall issue and solvable with available resources. Focusing on unsolvable problems is a waste, and solving minor ones achieves little. The art is in identifying the linchpin.

When Lou Gerstner took over a near-bankrupt IBM, many clamored to break the company up. Gerstner diagnosed that the company's many problems stemmed from one crux: its warring internal divisions prevented it from offering the integrated solutions that were its unique strength. He focused all his energy on solving that specific, solvable organizational problem, which saved the company.

A Good Guiding Policy Creates Coherent Action

Once you've diagnosed the crux, your solution takes the form of a 'guiding policy.' This is a clear, simple rule that channels all subsequent actions and decisions, making it easy for everyone in the organization to know what to do and, more importantly, what not to do.

When Steve Jobs returned to Apple, the company was drowning in a confusing array of products. The crux was a crippling lack of focus. His guiding policy was ruthless simplification, captured in his famous four-quadrant grid (Consumer/Pro, Desktop/Portable). This simple policy instantly clarified priorities for every engineer and marketer at Apple, creating a cascade of coherent actions.

Challenge-Based Leadership Trumps Vision-Based Leadership

Rumelt criticizes the modern obsession with 'visionary' leaders who paint inspiring pictures of the future. He champions 'challenge-based' leadership, where the leader’s primary job is to clearly articulate the nature of the core challenge the organization faces.

Instead of a CEO saying, 'Our vision is to be the #1 provider of eco-friendly packaging,' a challenge-based leader would say, 'Our main challenge is that our biodegradable plastic costs 30% more to produce than our competitors'. How do we close that gap? If we can solve that, we unlock the entire market.' This frames a concrete problem for the organization to attack, rather than offering a vague ambition.

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.