Psychology Memoir

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, HER Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed (Summary)

by Lori Gottlieb

Lori Gottlieb is a seasoned therapist who helps patients navigate their deepest struggles. But when an unexpected crisis shatters her own life, she finds herself on the other side of the couch, in the office of a quirky therapist named Wendell. Suddenly, the expert on human suffering is forced to confront her own messy, hilarious, and heartbreakingly human problems.

Your 'Presenting Problem' Is Rarely the Real Problem

People often seek therapy for a specific, surface-level issue, but this is usually just a ticket into the room. The real work begins when they uncover the deeper, underlying pain that is actually driving their behavior.

A successful Hollywood producer, John, comes to therapy because he's being a jerk to everyone in his life. But as Gottlieb digs deeper, it's revealed that his anger is a mask for profound loneliness and unacknowledged grief over the death of his young son years earlier.

Avoid 'Idiot Compassion'

Gottlieb introduces the concept of 'idiot compassion'—the act of telling people what they want to hear to avoid their immediate pain. True compassion involves telling them the hard truths they need to hear in order to actually grow.

A young, newlywed patient named Julie is diagnosed with terminal cancer. Instead of indulging her fantasies of miracle cures, Gottlieb gently helps her confront the reality of her diagnosis. This allows Julie to make meaningful choices with her remaining time, like mending her relationship with her estranged family.

You Can't Change the Past, But You Can Rewrite Your Story About It

Our suffering often comes not from events themselves, but from the restrictive stories we tell ourselves about them. Therapy is the process of editing that story into one that is more freeing and empowering.

After her boyfriend unexpectedly leaves her, Gottlieb's initial story is one of rejection and failure. Through her own therapy, she rewrites it as a story of liberation, realizing she was freed from a relationship that wasn't right, which opened the door to a different and better future.

Freedom Lies in Uncertainty

We crave certainty and control, but life is inherently uncertain. True freedom and peace come not from trying to predict the future, but from learning to tolerate ambiguity and embrace the unknown.

An older patient, Rita, vows to kill herself on her next birthday if her life doesn't improve. She's trapped by the idea that her life must follow a specific, happy script. Her journey is about letting go of that rigid expectation and finding meaning in the imperfect, uncertain present, ultimately choosing to live beyond her self-imposed deadline.

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.