Management Business Leadership

First, Break All the Rules: What the World's Greatest Managers Do Differently (Summary)

by Marcus Buckingham & Curt Coffman

Conventional wisdom says a manager's job is to help people overcome their weaknesses. What if that's a complete waste of time? Based on a massive Gallup study of over 80,000 managers, the world's best leaders don't try to fix people. They ignore weaknesses and instead focus obsessively on turning their employees' natural talents into world-class strengths.

Hire for Talent, Train for Skill

Great managers know you can't teach talent—a person's recurring patterns of thought, feeling, or behavior. You can only teach skills and knowledge. The most critical management decision, therefore, is selecting the right person with the innate talent for the role from the very beginning.

When hiring a salesperson, don't just look for someone with 10 years of experience. Look for someone with the innate talent of persuasiveness and empathy. A great manager would rather hire a charismatic bartender with zero sales experience than a mediocre salesperson with a decade-long resume, because charisma can't be taught.

Focus on Strengths, Not Weaknesses

The greatest room for growth is not in overcoming weaknesses, but in developing strengths. Spending time trying to fix what someone is bad at leads to incremental improvements at best. Great managers invest their time in honing and applying what's already there.

If you have a brilliant but disorganized strategist, don't send them to time-management courses. Instead, pair them with a highly organized administrative partner. This allows the strategist to spend 100% of their time on what they do best, generating a far greater return than if they had spent that time becoming a slightly less-disorganized strategist.

The Golden Rule is Wrong

The adage 'Treat others as you would like to be treated' is a recipe for mediocre management. Great managers understand that each person is motivated differently and needs to be managed according to their unique style, not the manager's.

One employee might thrive on public praise in a team meeting. Another might find that same public recognition deeply embarrassing and prefer a quiet, one-on-one 'thank you' from their manager. A great manager recognizes this and tailors their approach, rather than applying a one-size-fits-all rule.

You Can't Put In What Was Left Out

The core philosophy is that people don't change that much. Instead of trying to mold employees into a perfect ideal, great managers act as talent scouts, figuring out what makes each person unique and then designing their role to capitalize on those unique traits.

A manager at a luxury hotel noticed a housekeeper was shy with guests but loved arranging rooms perfectly, like a work of art. Instead of forcing her into more guest-facing roles, he made her the 'trainer for room presentation,' a role that leveraged her existing passion for perfection and made her a star performer.

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.