Media Studies Sociology Cultural Criticism

Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business (Summary)

by Neil Postman

In 1858, thousands of citizens stood for seven hours in the hot sun to listen to Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas engage in complex, multi-hour debates on slavery and constitutional law. Today, a presidential candidate is praised for a clever 30-second zinger in a televised debate. What happened? Neil Postman argues that the medium isn't just the message; the medium is the metaphor, and our dominant medium, television, has turned our entire public square into a vaudeville act.

Huxley Was Right, Not Orwell

Postman's chilling thesis is that our society is becoming a dystopia more aligned with Aldous Huxley's Brave New World than George Orwell's 1984. We aren't being controlled by an oppressive state that bans books; we are being controlled by our own insatiable appetite for entertainment, which makes us voluntarily give up reading and critical thought.

In 1984, control is maintained by inflicting pain. In Brave New World, it's maintained by inflicting pleasure. Postman saw the endless flood of television as a modern-day 'soma'—a drug that keeps the populace docile, distracted by trivia, and uninterested in the complex, challenging realities of the world.

The Medium Shapes the Message

Every medium has an inherent bias that shapes the content it delivers. A print culture encourages rationality, logic, and complexity. A visual, television-based culture demands simplicity, novelty, and performance, fundamentally altering what ideas can even be expressed.

Imagine trying to explain particle physics through a series of smoke signals. The medium itself would make the message absurd. Similarly, television's need for constant visual stimulation makes it an extremely poor medium for conveying nuanced political or philosophical arguments, which are inherently abstract and complex. Instead, it favors charismatic personalities and emotional imagery over substantive debate.

The News Creates a World of Incoherence

The format of television news, with its rapid-fire segments separated by commercials and the anchor's constant refrain of 'Now... this,' creates a disjointed and trivialized view of the world. It presents everything as equally important and equally forgettable.

A news broadcast might show 45 seconds of footage from a devastating war zone, then immediately cut to a celebrity interview or a commercial for a fast-food hamburger. This constant, context-free juxtaposition conditions us not to take anything too seriously, as another disconnected 'story' is always just moments away, rendering us passive and impotent.

Teaching as Entertainment

When television's values bleed into other domains like education, they corrupt the very purpose of the institution. The demand for education to be 'entertaining' undermines its goal of teaching sustained, disciplined thought.

Postman points to early educational shows like Sesame Street. While well-intentioned, he argues they teach children to love television, not to love learning. The show's fast pace and entertainment-first format conditions students to expect that learning should always be easy, fun, and require no sustained concentration, a poor preparation for the rigors of reading a book or solving a complex math problem.

Go deeper into these insights in the full book:
Buy on Amazon
Listen to the full audio book with an Audible Free Trial.
As an Amazon Associate, qualifying purchases help support this site.